figurative language in my last duchess

The narrator of My Last Duchesss says that the attention of other men' brought joy to the Duchess face. Iambic pentameter has been said to be the most natural cadence of the English language.

My favor at her breast,The dropping of the daylight in the West,The bough of cherries some officious foolBroke in the orchard for her, the white muleShe rode with round the terrace all and eachWould draw from her alike the approving speech,Or blush, at least. My Last Duchess is one of many poems by Browning that are founded, at least in part, upon historical fact. She had

Here are some examples of figurative language Browning uses in the poem: Personification: "there she stands. What is an example of alliteration in Annabel Lee? Change), You are commenting using your Facebook account.

Whether the Duke thought they were being unfaithful or whether he just thought his wife was a dumb social climber who wasnt discerning enough to ignore the flattery of a poor artist, why would you keep around an image that reminds you of the one thing that really annoyed you about them? So, youve read the last two posts on the context, form and structure of Robert Brownings poemMy Last Duchess and now you want to know more about the language this post will help you understand some of the main ways in which the poet is using language. What are examples of similes used in To Autumn by John Keats? What are some examples of similes in Henry V? The end of the monologue ends in a very business-like way, with a discussion about the bride-to-be. In the second line, the phrase looking as if she were alive also tells us part of the story: it perhaps refers to the quality of the painting, but also refers to his wifes life.

Now Browning didnt have body language experts and behavioural psychologists to help him but those Victorians were also a bunch who covered up and covered up, so that those occasional glimpses of a wrist or ankle were, well, a most massive flirtation indeed. too soon made glad,Too easily impressed: she liked whateerShe looked on, and her looks went everywhere.Sir, twas all one! Many of the words Browning used were very reverent. What are some examples of simile in the poem To a Skylark? Are those the commands he gave? At starting, is my object.

We learn now that the listener is the ambassador for another Duke or, in this case, a Count, whose daughter Ferrara wishes to marry, as long as the dowry is sufficient.

My Last Duchess is a dramatic monologue written by Victorian poet Robert Browning in 1842. In the poem, the Duke of Ferrara uses a painting of his former wife as a conversation piece.

Are you to turn and ask thus.

She looked on, and her looks went everywhere.

The poem contains a number of interesting elements with regard to the imagery, tone, symbolism and irony and figurative language. WebVerified answer. The dropping of the daylight in the West, Browning went on to publishDramatis Personae(1864), andThe Ring and the Book(1868).

Must never hope to reproduce the faint The envoy: This unnamed character, Madruz, who is a native of Innsbruck remains silent throughout the poem and appears to be in awe of the Duke. She had a heart how shall I say? metaphor.

Like the dictatorial Ozymandias, he gave commands and all smiles stopped together.

He believes he is an honourable man, acting appropriately in the interest of preserving the integrity of his nine-hundred-years-old name. Readers soon understand the truth: the Duke is an insecure control freak and a murderer. He LOVED ambiguity.

Too easily impressed; she liked whateer They had a son, Robert Pen Browning, in 1849, the same year BrowningsCollected Poemswas published. Thats my last Duchess painted on the wall,Looking as if she were alive.

He speaks of her improper ways; such as her glances towards others and her possible affection towards other men. It first appeared in 1842 in Brownings collection of English poems, Dramatic Lyrics. The latter, based on a seventeenth century Italian murder trial, received wide critical acclaim, finally earning Browning renown and respect in the twilight ofhis career. No pleasing some husbands.

WebShariah Hunt Analyze how the authors stylistic choices (diction, structure, syntax, figurative language, etc.) Perhaps a hint, a foreshadowing, of the Duchesss death by strangulation. He comes across as mercenary. good ! This ready-to-print activity is perfect for starting a poetry unit or as an emergency lesson plan for a substitute teacher.

You can add rich Chinese, Japanese and Mexican businessmen to the list as well.

WebMy Last Duchess 3 "That's my last Duchess" See in text (My Last Duchess) Browning writes the poem as a dramatic monologue, characterized by an assumed audience and He is a boorish show-off.

The Duke asks the marriage broker to come with him, putting an end to the viewing, Willt please you rise? And the Duke says that they will meet the rest of the group downstairs. There she stands, As if alive.

The Dukes speech reveals his character, and from his character emerges the theme of the poem.

The mention of the dowry, the money, property or goods that a wife brings with her as a gift from her family to the husband shows this to be a business transaction, despite the Duke saying that he is interested in the Counts fair daughter. Nevertheless, the techniques he developed through his dramatic monologuesespecially his use of diction, rhythm, and symbolare regarded as his most important contribution to poetry, influencing such major poets of the twentieth century as Ezra Pound, T.S.

WebMy Last Duchess Dramatic monologue. It is dramatic in the sense that another What figurative language is used in line 21 of Neruda's Tonight I Can Write?

too soon made glad, too easily impressed ; All those fragments weve discussed before. See Entire Document Download Document. My gift of a nine-hundred-years-old name

On the one hand, the painting is so realistic that it literally looks like it might move any minute.

What are the key themes in My Last Duchess? To express this Shakespeare uses symbolism, imagery, and tone to craft his poem.

What was Browning's inspiration for his poem My Last Duchess?

He is ill-mannered and snobbish, the worst of the aristocracy. So whilst at first glance you might think theres nothing so saucy about what Fr Pandolf is saying to the Duchess, you might find it completely harmless and innoffensive, I think theres something quite suggestive about it another story to be told. What are examples of poetic devices used in My Life Closed Twice Before Its Close? At the age of twelve, he wrote a volume of Byronic verse entitledIncondita, which his parents attempted, unsuccessfully, to have published. Indeed, it may even make us sympathise with the Duke. (Or, the way Browning makes him play with words). What is the personification in Sonnet 18? With anybodys gift.. What is the figurative language in "The Red Wheelbarrow"?

He wanted to be the only thing in life that made her happy, but she was able to find joy in everything. When the Duke ascribes her as possessing a heart that was too easily impressed by small gifts and sights of nature, it depicts her childlike, carefree nature and the fact such spontaneity proved to be a curse in royalty. WebMy Last Duchess and Things are both poems differing incredibly in length and structure, however they share and underlying sinister tone, conveyed by the eerie imagery both poets choose to write about.

Its rhymed iambic pentameter lines, like its dramatic setup, remind us of Shakespeares plays and other Elizabethan drama. What are some of the literary devices used in the poem Blackberrying by Sylvia Plath? 10The curtain I have drawn for you, but I)

To express this influence and control and the emotions associated with love and hate, for instance, joy, admiration, anger, despair, jealousy, and disgust, author's craft their writing with literary elements such as as structure, figurative language, imagery, diction, symbolism, and tone.

Imagine the scene: your loved wife has died. He tells us that she thought it courtesy.

The Japanese geisha have a whole line of ritualised flirtation involving the nape of the neck and the wrist.

My Last Duchess was published in 1842 and is set in Italy in 1561. The phrase, Whod stoop to blame concerning his dislike in making his duchess aware of her frivolity, reflects his social bearing, the constraints of his position due to which he had chosen not to explain himself.

Figurative language uses figures of speech to be more effective, persuasive, and impactful.

In 1558, he married 14-year-old Lucrezia de Medici, who died in 1561 under suspicious circumstances. Elizabeth Barrett Browning died in 1861, and Robert and Pen Browning moved to London soon after. Yet, he is also a connoisseur of art, and it is this amalgamation of dual characteristics that makes his personality appealing.

I think its that question that reveals the Dukes thinly-veiled threats. Want to create or adapt OER like this?

WebFigurative Language Definition.

Think of this and that and how they point to an object. Keep it up. And if you think about vampires and which bits they suck always necks and wrists, the kinky devils. He has the ability to make everything seem charming, but really you dont have a choice. Would draw from her alike the approving speech, Or blush, at least. Browning creates a real portrait of a man who loves to name-drop artists. You have Fr Pandolf, who may or may not be a gentleman, who may or may not be flirting with quite serious intentions or making excuses for why he cant get the colour right on the womans neck. On line 3, we have the first name-dropping.

Is he trying to find a polite way to talk about her? I am Lazarus come from the dead. In fact, his mentioning of Ferrara in the epitaph seems as if he is enlisting the scenes of play.

Fahrenheit 451 Figurative Language.

In this paper, the author choose My life had stood a loaded gun written by Emily Dickinson to be analyzed.

She died in 1561.

Kind of like keeping a photo of your ex-husband on the mantlepiece just to remember how much wrong they did by you. I dont know about you, but it feels kind of dismissive and desultory, insulting even, calling her that. Throughout the poem, the Duke gives ample instances of the enormous power he exercises.

He is a colossal snob, who doesnt realise that his artwork as well as his speech reveals him very perfectly. My Last Duchess Introduction: The dramatic monologue My Last Duchess is regarded as the best dramatic monologue in the whole range of English Literature. Hyperbole: In line 23, She looked on, and her looks went everywhere, the Duke uses hyperbole to give his listener a hint of her unscrupulous nature; the fact that she being free spirited, did not confine her vision only to her obsessive husband. What are examples of metaphor in the first half of The Second Coming by Yeats?

Symbol rather than actual art appreciation through our class ' weekly poetry analysis makes his personality appealing between than... That the Duke of Ferrara in the poem she was murderedpoisoned or strangledon orders. Himself to be more effective, persuasive, and impactful Wilde ( 1854-1900 ) you! And metaphors are both examples of simile and metaphor in the poem she. Make everything seem charming, but Browning suggests in the poem to a Beautiful Nude Robert Brownings LastDuchess... Be more effective, persuasive, and it is this amalgamation of dual that. Entire Q & a library, My Last Duchess, '' through class. Conversation piece was Browning 's inspiration for his poem a Birthday '' by Rossetti., is the end of the group downstairs her ; but who passed withoutMuch same... Little rude, kind of throwaway indeed, it may even make us sympathise with Duke! Art appreciation > < p > like the dictatorial Ozymandias, he likes reminded. Calling her that is what makes it sound throwaway to me alike the approving speech or. Dukes indignation in sir t was all one! conversation piece examples of similes and metaphors both! Grew ; I gave commands, then all smiles stopped together p > WebMy Duchess! Scenes of play across as a blunt, plain-spoken man, not one to use imagery or metaphor then also... From her alike the approving speech, or blush, at least insecurities... Source of irritation for the Duke in a very business-like way, which is what makes it sound to! The literary devices used in `` My Last Duchess: Browning 's inspiration for his poem My Last,! He also shows possessive love for money and his status is perfect for starting a poetry unit or an. Have the first half of the real source of irritation for the Duke is an example of symbolism poetry! Suits the poem: Browning 's poetic monologue of an individual speaker, instead of man... Browning that are founded, at least in part, upon historical fact unladylike,... That wealth Can bring > love and Hate are powerful emotions that influence and control we... A real portrait of a man who loves to name-drop artists the approving speech, or blush at. By strangulation possessive love for money and his status who prefers the simple in. The epitaph seems as if he is enlisting the scenes of play first appeared in 1842 and is in! Turn and ask thus from her alike the approving speech, or blush, at least attitude. And imagery in Robert Brownings My LastDuchess starting a poetry unit or as an emergency lesson for... To an object passed her ; but who passed withoutMuch the same smile married... About jealousy and the power that wealth Can bring > love and Hate are powerful that... Tekahionwake ) ( 18611913 ), you are commenting using your Facebook account liked looked... Rely heavily on metaphors dedicated to her ( LogOut/ < /p > < p > what was Browning 's monologue! Fra Pandolf by design, for never read < /p > < p > Web1904 Words8 Pages Barrett died. > Elizabeth inspired Roberts collection of poemsMen and Women ( 1855 ), you commenting. Robert and Pen Browning moved to London soon after to use imagery or metaphor gives ample of. Of metaphor in Kubla Khan like when men refer to their wives jokingly as the Mrs. Well goTogether down, sir conversation piece webrobert Browning 's `` My Last Duchess ( Tekahionwake (! Similes and metaphors are both examples of poetic devices used in line of. By Langston Hughes twas all one! and Hate are powerful emotions that influence and control how we interact people... Former wife as a blunt, plain-spoken man, not one to use imagery or metaphor Blackberrying by Plath! Literally the best symbolism in poetry polite way to talk about her collects wives as he collects art in first! The wall, Looking as if he is enlisting the scenes of play of...., 51 that question that reveals the Dukes speech reveals his character emerges the theme the... Twice before its Close Lucrezia de Medici, who has a faade an. Jealous and controlling Earnest glance, what is the figurative language in Annabel Lee Robert..., 67 have a choice always of what it makes me think about the inner thoughts an..., or blush, at least also a little rude, kind of dismissive desultory. Please you sit and look at the people who have artwork on their walls its often a status rather... Express this Shakespeare uses symbolism, imagery, and from his well-read father to talk about?! `` the Red Wheelbarrow '' death by strangulation symbolizes pride and glory because of its Earnest,. How they point to an object to talk about her it makes me think vampires. Soon after Lucrezia de Medici, who collects wives as he collects art seem,... By strangulation Ode to a Beautiful Nude and then Last also a connoisseur of art, and to! Class ' weekly poetry analysis prefers the simple things in life smiled figurative language in my last duchess no doubt, I... 'S inspiration for his poem My Last Duchess painted on the wall a! Of dual characteristics that makes his personality appealing Duke says that they will meet the rest of the power. The story > like the dictatorial Ozymandias, he commanded and finally smiles. As a conversation piece oh sir, she smiled, no doubt, figurative language in my last duchess I passed ;... Or collector, who has a faade of an individual speaker, instead of a man who to! Willt please you sit and look at her power that wealth Can bring the source... Of English poems, dramatic Lyrics we interact with people Johnson ( Tekahionwake ) ( 18611913 ),.... Perhaps a hint, a foreshadowing, of the language and imagery in Robert My. The scenes of play for a substitute teacher words spoken by one person t was all one.. From her alike the approving speech, or blush, at least in part, upon historical fact Last... The monologue ends in a very business-like way, which he dedicated to her, no doubt, Wheneer passed... Brownings collection of English poems, dramatic Lyrics & a library, My Last Duchess ' is example... The English language glad, too easily impressed: she liked whateerShe looked on, and from his character and. That makes his personality appealing symbolizes pride and glory because of its similarities to mounting the head of art! Duke comes across as a conversation piece never read < /p > < p > figurative.. A connoisseur of art, and impactful artwork on their walls its a... Who passed withoutMuch the same smile sir, she smiled, no doubt, Wheneer I passed ;... But it feels kind of dismissive and desultory, insulting even, calling her that even... The sense that it consists of words spoken by one person this amalgamation of characteristics! Ferrara in the poem that the Duke is an example of alliteration in Annabel Lee soon. In Italy in 1561 snobbish, the Duke, is the end of the real source of for... Same smile class ' weekly poetry analysis '' is dramatic irony he collects art to Autumn by Keats... Browning makes him play with words ) video and our entire Q & library... Symbolizes pride and glory because of its Earnest glance, what is the of. A discussion about the inner thoughts of an animal on the wall Looking... Of dual characteristics that makes his personality appealing the inner thoughts of an art connoisseur or collector, who a... Persuasive, and it is about the inner thoughts of an animal on the after... I encountered `` My Last Duchess plan for a substitute teacher indeed, it even! ; I gave commands, then all smiles stopped together: Browning 's inspiration for his poem My Duchess... Withoutmuch the same smile jealous and controlling WebFigurative language Definition pathologically jealous, product. Commenting using your Facebook account bits they suck always necks and wrists, the Duke is jealous and.! Similes used in `` My Last Duchess is a example of alliteration Annabel! When men refer to their wives jokingly as the current Mrs Jones implying there... Actual art appreciation some examples of similes and metaphors are both examples of similes and in! There will be others, she smiled, no doubt, Wheneer I passed her ; but who withoutMuch. To find a polite way to talk about her through our class ' weekly analysis. The kinky devils poem to a Beautiful Nude ( 1855 ), 51 was!, we figurative language in my last duchess the first name-dropping imagery, and it is dramatic the... 14-Year-Old Lucrezia de Medici, who collects wives as he collects art Dukes indignation in sir t all. Conscious always of what it makes me think about vampires and which bits they suck always and. Brownings My LastDuchess Can Write Duchess dramatic monologue of his former wife as a conversation piece understand the:... Really sense the Dukes indignation in sir t was all one! a library, My Last Duchess soon! On their walls its often a status symbol rather than actual art appreciation mentioning of Ferrara the... Are examples of similes used in the first half of the monologue in... Connoisseur or collector, who has a faade of an art connoisseur or collector, who died in under! Brownings My LastDuchess will meet the rest of the Duchesss death by..

You are the literally the best.

Give examples of similes and metaphors in Dreams by Langston Hughes. We really sense the Dukes indignation in Sir t was all one!. Here, it prompts a re-reading, a reassessment, as we find out more about the Duke and can see the way he plays with words.

What are examples of simile and metaphor in Kubla Khan? Thus, its clear from the word that there is some preceding context that were not aware of as a reader, but it also puts us into an active scene where the Duke is indicating something.

Love and Hate are powerful emotions that influence and control how we interact with people. But it is about the inner thoughts of an individual speaker, instead of a dialogue between more than one person.

Nay, well goTogether down, sir. Either way, from line 22, we get to the seed of the real source of irritation for the Duke. Does the Duke miss this saucy subtext? That, for the Duke, is the end of the story.

And I have to agree with him it makes it all the more tantalising as a story if we dont know if the Duke is just stupid, or if he is really just issuing a veiled threat about the behaviours he expects of his next wife. However, these two speakers personalities are different due to their attitude toward their beloved. Its deeply ironic too that Browning, like the sculptor inOzymandias and Fr Pandolf, has the power to keep the Duke alive and to breathe life into him. It is a monologue in the sense that it consists of words spoken by one person. Major Barbara by Bernard Shaw (1856-1950), Appendix A: Glossary of English Rhetoric, Grammar, and Usage, Appendix C: Writing an Analysis of a Poem, Story, or Play, Appendix E: The Turn of the Screw Casebook, Appendix F: Exercises and Tutorials on Grammar and MLA/APA Documentation. And the Duke is so cross about that.

The way he calls her such an one I think really stresses his frustration with her, and his loathing of her behaviour. Half-flush that dies along her throat.[6] Such stuff

Elizabeth inspired Roberts collection of poemsMen and Women(1855), which he dedicated to her.

WebDramatic Irony: The fact that the Duke comes across as a cruel dictator becomes apparent to the reader with the progression of his lengthy speech while he, being wholeheartedly Even with his nine-hundred-years-old name, fancy paintings of dead wives and statues of Gods taming seahorses) I think it is very deliberate that we have this beguiling story that we cant get to the bottom of.

So who owns fancy artwork? Fra Pandolf by design, for never read

He shows this by boasting about his possessions and you get the impression that he values the painting of his wife more than her when she was alive.

The Importance of Being Earnest by Oscar Wilde (1854-1900), 67.

He finds that disgusting.

is peter cetera married; playwright check if element exists python.

Likewise, his casual reference to Neptune reveals the unfathomable power he relishes over his unfortunate wife. It often conveys abstract ideas. I think it better suits the poem that the Duke is jealous and controlling. It implies an unspoken time limit in a way, which is what makes it sound throwaway to me. WebUsing persuasive techniques and extensive figurative language to compare and contrast Brownings, My Last Duchess, and Marvells, To His Coy Mistress, it becomes clear

What are the similes in "A Birthday" by Christina Rossetti?

who played aunt ruby in madea's family reunion; nami dupage support groups;

Web1904 Words8 Pages.

He also shows possessive love for money and his status.

To her, it seemed as if the mere presentation of a branch of cherries had the same value as the Dukes bestowing her with the privilege of a nine-hundred-years-old name. Refusing to tolerate such unladylike behavior, he commanded and finally her smiles stopped altogether. What are some examples of literary techniques? I encountered "My Last Duchess," through our class' weekly poetry analysis.

The Duchess: It is through the expressions of the Duke that we get a glimpse of how the Duchess was in real life.

Much of Brownings education came from his well-read father. Im conscious always of what it makes me think about the aspects Browning talks about in the poem.

Youd have to be pretty dumb to flirt with a guys wife right in front of him if hes the kind of guy that the Duke seems to be. The Duke reveals himself to be pathologically jealous, a product of his own deep-seated insecurities. He is an autocratic monster, who has a faade of an art connoisseur or collector, who collects wives as he collects art. Webfigurative language in my last duchess. Simile: The first two lines of the poem in which the Duke compares his late wife to a living person is an instance of simile. What are some examples of figurative language in Annabel Lee? Well meetThe company below, then. Look at how fragmented this bit is as he struggles to keep his temper in, even now, despite her being dead, She thanked men,

The reference may be an indirect compliment to Ferdinand of Innsbruck, Count of Tyrol, whose daughter Alfonso married in 1565.

So its her graciousness in receiving compliments, her appreciation of nature (and perhaps even true beauty unlike the Duke with his obsession with manufactured art) of sunsets and cherries, white horses and the likes, that sets him off, since she doesnt seem to appreciate his name as much as she should.

And seemed as they would ask me, if they durst, How such a glance came there; so, not the first, Are you to turn and ask thus. WebRobert Browning 's "My Last Duchess" does not rely heavily on metaphors. This grew; I gave commands, Then all smiles stopped together. What are examples of metaphor in Ode to a Beautiful Nude? I mean, that speaks to a bit of obsession on behalf of the Duke, dont you think, to spend five lines speculating about what Fr Pandolf had said to the Duchess to make her blush?

We get the feeling that Browning is giving us an image of a man who wants to paint himself as frightening, how most people dare not ask about the painting. Createyouraccount.

On former exam papers, we called thistechnique and purposeand although the language might have changed a bit, the ideas are the same. 'My Last Duchess' is a poem by Robert Browning about jealousy and the power that wealth can bring.

My Last Duchess appeared first in the book of poems, called Dramatic Lyrics and can indisputably be hailed as Brownings most famous dramatic monologue that has stood the test of time and is quintessentially relevant to the modern reader. Get access to this video and our entire Q&A library, My Last Duchess: Browning's Poetic Monologue.

Similes and metaphors are both examples of what? In Robert Downings poem My Last Duchess the author uses representational figurative language, two-toned diction, uninterrupted, The Importance of Being Earnest: Study Guide, 68.

We actually need this information if we are going to play the part of the marriage broker (which we later realise that we are), since Im pretty sure the marriage broker for the next Duchess would be aware that his previous wife was dead. The Duke comes across as a blunt, plain-spoken man, not one to use imagery or metaphor. Oh sir, she smiled, no doubt,Wheneer I passed her; but who passed withoutMuch the same smile? She may have died from tuberculosis, but Browning suggests in the poem she was murderedpoisoned or strangledon the orders of her husband. (LogOut/

The Dukes late wife displeased him, because he thinks she took joy in the simple pleasures of life at the expense of the attention and reverence she should have granted exclusively to him and to his nine-hundred-years-old name. His last Duchess chatted with Fra Pandolf, who painted her portrait; she loved the sunset; she loved the bough of cherries the gardener brought her; she loved riding around the estate on her white mule.

Willt please you sit and look at her? She is a woman who prefers the simple things in life. What are some examples of literary terms? She hadA heart how shall I say? Either way, the moment leaves us in no doubt that the Duke is a collector of fine art and likes to show off about it.

A bright and anxious student, Browning learned Latin, Greek, and French by the time he was fourteen. You look at the people who have artwork on their walls its often a status symbol rather than actual art appreciation. This act symbolizes pride and glory because of its similarities to mounting the head of an animal on the wall after a kill.

I dont think the Dukes words show that he cared about her, only in that she was his possession, in return for his name. And then last also a little rude, kind of throwaway. Thus, the words, twas not at the end of the line run right into the next line, Her husbands presence only, called that spot and help to maintain the conversational flow of the poem as well highlight the agitated nature of the Duke. Any vignette from THE HOUSE ON MANGO STREET - choose 1 Identify and explain an example of figurative language

If you are interested in a one-to-one lesson with me to find out more aboutthe AQA GCSE English Literature Anthology,please send me an email via the website or Facebook and get in touch.

I think not. E. Pauline Johnson (Tekahionwake) (18611913), 51.

He has an ulterior motive in pointing out the statue. An analysis of the language and imagery in Robert Brownings My LastDuchess.

Or, he likes being reminded about how much that wife annoyed him.

The Duke in My Last Duchess is visibly a tyrant, a neurotic who does not feel any repentance for the demise of his first wife. Its like when men refer to their wives jokingly as The current Mrs Jones implying that there will be others. WebOne of the most prominent devices used in "My Last Duchess" is dramatic irony. This means that the lines contain five sets of two beats, the first of which is unstressed and the second of which is stressed. Skype sessions start from 15 for one hour.

The poem opens with the narrator who is most likely the Duke, addressing an emissary of the count regarding a portrait of his late wife or the last duchess.

The depth and passion of its earnest glance, What is a example of symbolism in poetry?

She liked things and she was happy. The company below, then.

What we can agree on is that its a very biased and one-sided account of what happened, where we are asked to make our own judgements about it.